See more at the Statistics Forum (of course).

## Statistics plagiarism scandal

Posted by Andrew on 17 May 2011, 3:47 pm

See more at the Statistics Forum (of course).

## Recent Comments

- Shravan Vasishth on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Sam on Damn, I was off by a factor of 2!
- Rahul on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Rahul on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Eric de Souza on
~~Wegman~~~~Frey~~~~Hauser~~~~Weick~~~~Fischer~~~~Dr. Anil Potti~~Stapel comes clean - Shravan Vasishth on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- question on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- question on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Rolf Degen on
~~Wegman~~~~Frey~~~~Hauser~~~~Weick~~~~Fischer~~~~Dr. Anil Potti~~Stapel comes clean - Rahul on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- jrc on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Shravan Vasishth on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Anonymous on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Andrew on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- artkqtarks on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- artkqtarks on I’d like to see a preregistered replication on this one
- Andrew on Damn, I was off by a factor of 2!
- Hesse on Damn, I was off by a factor of 2!
- Rahul on
~~Wegman~~~~Frey~~~~Hauser~~~~Weick~~~~Fischer~~~~Dr. Anil Potti~~Stapel comes clean - Raghuveer Parthasarathy on Hey, I just wrote my April Fool’s post!

## Categories

If none of the co-authors was the plagiarist, then the authors still used someone else's writing in their paper. That's plagiarism, in many people's use of the term. At best they didn't know that the mystery person was in fact plagiarising, but by using the material they took on responsibility for it and so _they_ were plagiarising.

Of course, there's a spectrum of practices. I heard of a leading U.S. statistician who delegates some of his book reviews to smart graduate students. The (very grateful) ex-student who told me said, in effect, it's just his way of working. He makes the deal evident beforehand and makes it up to you in other ways by superb mentoring. Papers too, in other cases?